Define Eco Gnome / Eco Calc parity target for Eco App #173

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-07-29 05:57:30 +00:00 by coilyco-ops · 0 comments

coilyco-ops commented

2026-07-29 05:57:30 +00:00

Member

Outcome

Define the Eco Gnome / Eco Calc parity target for eco-app.coilysiren.me: the player jobs worth matching, the current capability gap, and the ordered product slices that justify implementation.

This is a successor to the self-hosting work in #40 and the practical-usefulness design in #98. It does not presume that Eco App should copy either product's UI or every feature.

Scope

Compare the player-facing workflows offered by Eco Gnome and Eco Calc with the current Sirens Eco App.
Separate parity candidates into: already covered, reusable upstream capability, Eco App-native opportunity, blocked by data, and deliberately out of scope.
Establish a prioritised parity matrix with evidence, including data provenance and ownership.
Recommend only bounded follow-up issues that improve a specific player outcome.

Acceptance

A source-backed parity matrix covers the material calculator workflows.
Each gap has a recommended disposition and an identified data/ownership dependency.
The parent records a proposed first slice, success evidence, and explicit non-goals.
Implementation work is created only after the matrix supports it.

Non-goals

No fork, redesign, or replacement of Eco Gnome is assumed.
No UI cloning, production deployment, mod rollout, or new data exporter is performed here.
This does not reopen completed #40 or #98 work.

Context

#40 — self-hosted Eco Gnome
#98 — practical-usefulness design and prior completed implementation graph
#165 — historical price/bell-curve backlog
Discord: eco-app.coilysiren.me feature inventory

Research plan

Lane	Issue	Purpose	Sequence
Incumbent capabilities	#174	Evidence for Eco Gnome/Eco Calc workflows and reuse constraints.	Starts now.
Eco App baseline	#175	Verified current capability/data inventory.	Starts now.
Sirens demand	#176	Community evidence and prioritisation inputs.	Starts now.
Parity decision	This issue	Reconcile evidence into a matrix and select the first justified slice.	After #174–#176.

The lanes are independent. This parent must explicitly mark each candidate as adopt, integrate, build, defer, or reject before new implementation issues are created.

## Outcome Define the Eco Gnome / Eco Calc parity target for `eco-app.coilysiren.me`: the player jobs worth matching, the current capability gap, and the ordered product slices that justify implementation. This is a successor to the self-hosting work in #40 and the practical-usefulness design in #98. It does not presume that Eco App should copy either product's UI or every feature. ## Scope - Compare the player-facing workflows offered by Eco Gnome and Eco Calc with the current Sirens Eco App. - Separate parity candidates into: already covered, reusable upstream capability, Eco App-native opportunity, blocked by data, and deliberately out of scope. - Establish a prioritised parity matrix with evidence, including data provenance and ownership. - Recommend only bounded follow-up issues that improve a specific player outcome. ## Acceptance - A source-backed parity matrix covers the material calculator workflows. - Each gap has a recommended disposition and an identified data/ownership dependency. - The parent records a proposed first slice, success evidence, and explicit non-goals. - Implementation work is created only after the matrix supports it. ## Non-goals - No fork, redesign, or replacement of Eco Gnome is assumed. - No UI cloning, production deployment, mod rollout, or new data exporter is performed here. - This does not reopen completed #40 or #98 work. ## Context - #40 — self-hosted Eco Gnome - #98 — practical-usefulness design and prior completed implementation graph - #165 — historical price/bell-curve backlog - Discord: [eco-app.coilysiren.me feature inventory](https://discord.com/channels/1300204416229441587/1531686534997213275/1531686534997213275) ## Research plan | Lane | Issue | Purpose | Sequence | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Incumbent capabilities | #174 | Evidence for Eco Gnome/Eco Calc workflows and reuse constraints. | Starts now. | | Eco App baseline | #175 | Verified current capability/data inventory. | Starts now. | | Sirens demand | #176 | Community evidence and prioritisation inputs. | Starts now. | | Parity decision | This issue | Reconcile evidence into a matrix and select the first justified slice. | After #174–#176. | The lanes are independent. This parent must explicitly mark each candidate as adopt, integrate, build, defer, or reject before new implementation issues are created.

coilyco-ops added the

autonomy

async-consult

priority

labels

2026-07-29 05:57:30 +00:00

coilyco-ops referenced this issue

2026-07-29 05:57:53 +00:00

Research Eco Gnome and Eco Calc capabilities by player workflow #174

coilyco-ops referenced this issue

2026-07-29 05:57:53 +00:00

Audit current Eco App capabilities relevant to calculator parity #175