coilyco-flight-deck/ward

Fork

You've already forked ward

Code Issues 106 Pull requests 1 Projects Releases 737 Packages Wiki Activity Actions

Parked: evaluate ReviewService for advisor, QA, and review internals #1250

New issue

Open

opened 2026-07-14 08:32:18 +00:00 by coilyco-ops · 0 comments

coilyco-ops commented

2026-07-14 08:32:18 +00:00

Member

Copy link

Decision

Parked from coilysiren/inbox#210.

The issue is for evaluation only. It is not approval to extract advisor, QA, or review-panel code.

Scope

Evaluate whether advisor, QA, and review internals should move behind a ReviewService seam.
Keep workflow comments, issue-ref parsing, comment posting, and command mounting in Ward unless later approved.
Recommend whether to proceed, split further, or abandon.

Non-goals

Do not move code.
Do not create an external service.
Do not change workflow-comment behavior.

Parent: coilysiren/inbox#210.

## Decision Parked from coilysiren/inbox#210. The issue is for evaluation only. It is not approval to extract advisor, QA, or review-panel code. ## Scope - Evaluate whether advisor, QA, and review internals should move behind a ReviewService seam. - Keep workflow comments, issue-ref parsing, comment posting, and command mounting in Ward unless later approved. - Recommend whether to proceed, split further, or abandon. ## Non-goals - Do not move code. - Do not create an external service. - Do not change workflow-comment behavior. Parent: coilysiren/inbox#210.

coilyco-ops added the

consult

labels

2026-07-14 08:32:18 +00:00

coilysiren referenced this issue

2026-07-14 15:27:09 +00:00

director should emit colorized, space buffered, visually distinct messages about the categories of actions its performing on startup #1283

No Branch/Tag specified

main

issue-1082

issue-1460

issue-1459-daemonless-alias

issue-1454

issue-1453

issue-1301

issue-1443

issue-1283

issue-1447

release

issue-1166

issue-1139

issue-1307

issue-1308

issue-1309

issue-1435

issue-1430

issue-1428

issue-1388

issue-1420

issue-1422

issue-1423

issue-1417

issue-1408

issue-1335

issue-1412

issue-1411

issue-1402

issue-1403

issue-1402-scoop-best-effort

issue-1336

issue-1334

issue-1393

issue-1338

issue-1397

issue-1392

issue-1339

issue-1340

issue-1300

issue-1288

issue-1304

issue-1270

issue-1381

issue-1244

issue-1227

issue-1380

issue-996

issue-1016

issue-1375

issue-1371

issue-1372

issue-1370

issue-1364

issue-1175

issue-1234

issue-1360

issue-1358

issue-1353

issue-1242

issue-1346

issue-1347

issue-1342

issue-1321

issue-1073-rebased

issue-1237-friction-events

issue-1320

issue-1344

issue-1073

issue-1275

issue-1332-replacement

issue-1296

issue-1330-replacement

issue-1224-rebased

issue-1323

issue-993

issue-1243

issue-871

issue-1298

issue-1315

issue-1312

issue-1314

issue-1313

issue-1310

issue-1282

issue-1224

issue-1173

issue-1000

issue-1007

issue-1281

issue-1011

issue-1006-recovery-note

issue-998

issue-1221

issue-1240

issue-1170

issue-1239

issue-1172

issue-1168

issue-1174

issue-1201

issue-1112

issue-1179

issue-1246

issue-1247

issue-1245

issue-1050

issue-1105

issue-1041

issue-1120

issue-1197

issue-1111

issue-1225

issue-1196

issue-1171

issue-1194

issue-1203

issue-1198

issue-1202

issue-1200

issue-1213

issue-1205

issue-1207

issue-1209

issue-1206

issue-1195

issue-1191

issue-1188

issue-1180

issue-1147

issue-1149

issue-1134

issue-1143

issue-1145

issue-1140

issue-1094

issue-1129

issue-1142

stash/agentic-os-image-default-rename

fix/test-env-isolation

docs/features-two-stage-release

fix/promote-server-scheme

fix/smartdefaults-error-source

feat/two-stage-release

issue-1086

fix/placeholder-sentinels

fix/migrate-off-cli-guard-dispatch

fix/test-yml-duplicate-main-gate

issue-1014-landing-fix

issue-911-pr

issue-1109

issue-1008

issue-999

issue-861

issue-1074

issue-1076

issue-1049

issue-1039

issue-994

issue-991

issue-1020

issue-1067

issue-913

issue-982

issue-1034

issue-1005

issue-1031

issue-990

issue-1062

issue-995

issue-1057

issue-905

issue-911

issue-1042

issue-1021

issue-1009

issue-1014

issue-1001

issue-978

issue-985

issue-950

issue-979

issue-977

issue-971

issue-935

issue-970

issue-969

issue-956

issue-965

issue-964

issue-962-restore-readme

issue-951

issue-958-container-config-guard

issue-704

issue-697

issue-896

issue-885

issue-876

issue-895

issue-893

issue-940

issue-923

issue-942

issue-952

issue-952-director

issue-936

issue-937

issue-931

issue-924

issue-920

issue-635

issue-903

issue-892

issue-874

issue-879

issue-890

issue-910

issue-875

issue-897

issue-894

issue-637

issue-842

issue-834

issue-860

issue-541

issue-723

issue-830-github-authoritative

issue-853

issue-634

issue-845

issue-846

issue-843

issue-496

issue-832

issue-777

issue-778

issue-836

issue-700

issue-695

issue-124-share-parser

issue-671

issue-722

issue-694

issue-824

issue-640

issue-735

issue-641

issue-642

issue-818

issue-812

issue-733-clean

issue-804

issue-805

issue-803

issue-735-remove-director-consult

issue-797

issue-801

issue-795

issue-791

issue-790

issue-787

issue-780

issue-737-defer-signoz

issue-732

issue-737-signoz-deferred

issue-734

issue-736

issue-744

issue-769

issue-767

issue-760

issue-763

ward-salvage/ward-c6aa5da9

ward-salvage/ward-94dd7346

issue-729

ward-salvage/ward-58aa3fe3

issue-733

ward-salvage/ward-ff6c509f

ward-salvage/ward-e80f0460

issue-737

ward-salvage/ward-3e2e4760

issue-731

ward-salvage/ward-649addd7

ward-salvage/ward-890e4d29

ward-salvage/ward-645b750b

ward-salvage/ward-bf851a72

ward-salvage/ward-98c8652f

ward-salvage/ward-bb10b620

issue-724

ward-salvage/ward-1ee9be1c

ward-salvage/ward-d18595f6

issue-124

ward-salvage/ward-5f914692

ward-salvage/ward-6ca05cbd

ward-salvage/ward-14f676cf

ward-salvage/ward-de811c20

ward-salvage/ward-eba3e824

ward-salvage/ward-16eb4ad0

ward-salvage/ward-c58e9c43

ward-salvage/ward-7487270b

v0.769.0

v0.768.0

v0.767.0

v0.766.0

v0.765.0

v0.764.0

v0.763.0

v0.762.0

v0.761.0

v0.760.0

v0.759.0

v0.758.0

v0.757.0

v0.756.0

v0.755.0

v0.754.0

v0.753.0

v0.752.0

v0.751.0

v0.750.0

v0.749.0

v0.748.0

v0.747.0

v0.746.0

v0.745.0

v0.744.0

v0.743.0

v0.742.0

v0.741.0

v0.740.0

v0.739.0

v0.738.0

v0.737.0

v0.736.0

v0.735.0

v0.734.0

v0.733.0

v0.732.0

v0.731.0

v0.730.0

v0.729.0

v0.728.0

v0.727.0

v0.726.0

v0.725.0

v0.724.0

v0.723.0

v0.722.0

v0.721.0

v0.720.0

v0.719.0

v0.718.0

v0.717.0

v0.716.0

v0.715.0

v0.714.0

v0.713.0

v0.712.0

v0.711.0

v0.710.0

v0.709.0

v0.708.0

v0.707.0

v0.706.0

v0.705.0

v0.704.0

v0.703.0

v0.702.0

v0.701.0

v0.700.0

v0.699.0

v0.698.0

v0.697.0

v0.696.0

v0.695.0

v0.694.0

v0.693.0

v0.692.0

v0.691.0

v0.690.0

v0.689.0

v0.688.0

v0.687.0

v0.686.0

v0.685.0

v0.684.0

v0.683.0

v0.682.0

v0.681.0

v0.680.0

v0.679.0

v0.678.0

v0.677.0

v0.676.0

v0.675.0

v0.674.0

v0.673.0

v0.672.0

v0.671.0

v0.670.0

v0.669.0

v0.668.0

v0.667.0

v0.666.0

v0.665.0

v0.664.0

v0.663.0

v0.662.0

v0.661.0

v0.660.0

v0.659.0

v0.658.0

v0.657.0

v0.656.0

v0.655.0

v0.654.0

v0.653.0

v0.652.0

v0.651.0

v0.650.0

v0.649.0

v0.648.0

v0.647.0

v0.646.0

v0.645.0

v0.644.0

v0.643.0

v0.642.0

v0.641.0

v0.640.0

v0.639.0

v0.638.0

v0.637.0

v0.636.0

v0.635.0

v0.634.0

v0.633.0

v0.632.0

v0.631.0

v0.630.0

v0.629.0

v0.628.0

v0.627.0

v0.626.0

v0.625.0

v0.624.0

v0.623.0

v0.622.0

v0.621.0

v0.620.0

v0.619.0

v0.618.0

v0.617.0

v0.616.0

v0.615.0

v0.614.0

v0.613.0

v0.612.0

v0.611.0

v0.610.0

v0.609.0

v0.608.0

v0.607.0

v0.606.0

v0.605.0

v0.604.0

v0.603.0

v0.602.0

v0.601.0

v0.600.0

v0.599.0

v0.598.0

v0.597.0

v0.596.0

v0.595.0

v0.594.0

v0.593.0

v0.592.0

v0.591.0

v0.590.0

v0.589.0

v0.588.0

v0.587.0

v0.586.0

v0.585.0

v0.584.0

v0.583.0

v0.582.0

v0.581.0

v0.580.0

v0.579.0

v0.578.0

v0.577.0

v0.576.0

v0.575.0

v0.574.0

v0.573.0

v0.572.0

v0.571.0

v0.570.0

v0.569.0

v0.568.0

v0.567.0

v0.566.0

v0.565.0

v0.564.0

v0.563.0

v0.562.0

v0.561.0

v0.560.0

v0.559.0

v0.558.0

v0.557.0

v0.556.0

v0.555.0

v0.554.0

v0.553.0

v0.552.0

v0.551.0

v0.550.0

v0.549.0

v0.548.0

v0.547.0

v0.546.0

v0.545.0

v0.544.0

v0.543.0

v0.542.0

v0.541.0

v0.540.0

v0.539.0

v0.538.0

v0.537.0

v0.536.0

v0.535.0

v0.534.0

v0.533.0

v0.532.0

v0.531.0

v0.530.0

v0.529.0

v0.528.0

v0.527.0

v0.526.0

v0.525.0

v0.524.0

v0.523.0

v0.522.0

v0.521.0

v0.520.0

v0.519.0

v0.518.0

v0.517.0

v0.516.0

v0.515.0

v0.514.0

v0.513.0

v0.512.0

v0.511.0

v0.510.0

v0.509.0

v0.508.0

v0.507.0

v0.506.0

v0.505.0

v0.504.0

v0.503.0

v0.502.0

v0.501.0

v0.500.0

v0.499.0

v0.498.0

v0.497.0

v0.496.0

v0.495.0

v0.494.0

v0.493.0

v0.492.0

v0.491.0

v0.490.0

v0.489.0

v0.488.0

v0.487.0

v0.486.0

v0.485.0

v0.484.0

v0.483.0

v0.482.0

v0.481.0

v0.480.0

v0.479.0

v0.478.0

v0.477.0

v0.476.0

v0.475.0

v0.474.0

v0.473.0

v0.472.0

v0.471.0

v0.470.0

v0.469.0

v0.468.0

v0.467.0

v0.466.0

v0.465.0

v0.464.0

v0.463.0

v0.462.0

v0.461.0

v0.460.0

v0.459.0

v0.458.0

v0.457.0

v0.456.0

v0.455.0

v0.454.0

v0.453.0

v0.452.0

v0.451.0

v0.450.0

v0.449.0

v0.448.0

v0.447.0

v0.446.0

v0.445.0

v0.444.0

v0.443.0

v0.442.0

v0.441.0

v0.440.0

v0.439.0

v0.438.0

v0.437.0

v0.436.0

v0.435.0

v0.434.0

v0.433.0

v0.432.0

v0.431.0

v0.430.0

v0.429.0

v0.428.0

v0.427.0

v0.426.0

v0.425.0

v0.424.0

v0.423.0

v0.422.0

v0.421.0

v0.420.0

v0.419.0

v0.418.0

v0.417.0

v0.416.0

v0.415.0

v0.414.0

v0.413.0

v0.412.0

v0.411.0

v0.410.0

v0.409.0

v0.408.0

v0.407.0

v0.406.0

v0.405.0

v0.404.0

v0.403.0

v0.402.0

v0.401.0

v0.400.0

v0.399.0

v0.398.0

v0.397.0

v0.396.0

v0.395.0

v0.394.0

v0.393.0

v0.392.0

v0.391.0

v0.390.0

v0.389.0

v0.388.0

v0.387.0

v0.386.0

v0.385.0

v0.384.0

v0.383.0

v0.382.0

v0.381.0

v0.380.0

v0.379.0

v0.378.0

v0.377.0

v0.376.0

v0.375.0

v0.374.0

v0.373.0

v0.372.0

v0.371.0

v0.370.0

v0.369.0

v0.368.0

v0.367.0

v0.366.0

v0.365.0

v0.364.0

v0.363.0

v0.362.0

v0.361.0

v0.360.0

v0.359.0

v0.358.0

v0.357.0

v0.356.0

v0.355.0

v0.354.0

v0.353.0

v0.352.0

v0.351.0

v0.350.0

v0.349.0

v0.348.0

v0.347.0

v0.346.0

v0.345.0

v0.344.0

v0.343.0

v0.342.0

v0.341.0

v0.340.0

v0.339.0

v0.338.0

v0.337.0

v0.336.0

v0.335.0

v0.334.0

v0.333.0

v0.332.0

v0.331.0

v0.330.0

v0.329.0

v0.328.0

v0.327.0

v0.326.0

v0.325.0

v0.324.0

v0.323.0

v0.322.0

v0.321.0

v0.320.0

v0.319.0

v0.318.0

v0.317.0

v0.316.0

v0.315.0

v0.314.0

v0.313.0

v0.312.0

v0.311.0

v0.310.0

v0.309.0

v0.308.0

v0.307.0

v0.306.0

v0.305.0

v0.304.0

v0.303.0

v0.302.0

v0.301.0

v0.300.0

v0.299.0

v0.298.0

v0.297.0

v0.296.0

v0.295.0

v0.294.0

v0.293.0

v0.292.0

v0.291.0

v0.290.0

v0.289.0

v0.288.0

v0.287.0

v0.286.0

v0.285.0

v0.284.0

v0.283.0

v0.282.0

v0.281.0

v0.280.0

v0.279.0

v0.278.0

v0.277.0

v0.276.0

v0.275.0

v0.274.0

v0.273.0

v0.272.0

v0.271.0

v0.270.0

v0.269.0

v0.268.0

v0.267.0

v0.266.0

v0.265.0

v0.264.0

v0.263.0

v0.262.0

v0.261.0

v0.260.0

v0.259.0

v0.258.0

v0.257.0

v0.256.0

v0.255.0

v0.254.0

v0.253.0

v0.252.0

v0.251.0

v0.250.0

v0.249.0

v0.248.0

v0.247.0

v0.246.0

v0.245.0

v0.244.0

v0.243.0

v0.242.0

v0.241.0

v0.240.0

v0.239.0

v0.238.0

v0.237.0

v0.236.0

v0.235.0

v0.234.0

v0.233.0

v0.232.0

v0.231.0

v0.230.0

v0.229.0

v0.228.0

v0.227.0

v0.226.0

v0.225.0

v0.224.0

v0.223.0

v0.222.0

v0.221.0

v0.220.0

v0.219.0

v0.218.0

v0.217.0

v0.216.0

v0.215.0

v0.214.0

v0.213.0

v0.212.0

v0.211.0

v0.210.0

v0.209.0

v0.208.0

v0.207.0

v0.206.0

v0.205.0

v0.204.0

v0.203.0

v0.202.0

v0.201.0

v0.200.0

v0.199.0

v0.198.0

v0.197.0

v0.196.0

v0.195.0

v0.194.0

v0.193.0

v0.192.0

v0.191.0

v0.190.0

v0.189.0

v0.188.0

v0.187.0

v0.186.0

v0.185.0

v0.184.0

v0.183.0

v0.182.0

v0.181.0

v0.180.0

v0.179.0

v0.178.0

v0.177.0

v0.176.0

v0.175.0

v0.174.0

v0.173.0

v0.172.0

v0.171.0

v0.170.0

v0.169.0

v0.168.0

v0.167.0

v0.166.0

v0.165.0

v0.164.0

v0.163.0

v0.162.0

v0.161.0

v0.160.0

v0.159.0

v0.158.0

v0.157.0

v0.156.0

v0.155.0

v0.154.0

v0.153.0

v0.152.0

v0.151.0

v0.150.0

v0.149.0

v0.148.0

v0.147.0

v0.146.0

v0.145.0

v0.144.0

v0.143.0

v0.142.0

v0.141.0

v0.140.0

v0.139.0

v0.138.0

v0.137.0

v0.136.0

v0.135.0

v0.134.0

v0.133.0

v0.132.0

v0.131.0

v0.130.0

v0.129.0

v0.128.0

v0.127.0

v0.126.0

v0.125.0

v0.124.0

v0.123.0

v0.122.0

v0.121.0

v0.120.0

v0.119.0

v0.118.0

v0.117.0

v0.116.0

v0.115.0

v0.114.0

v0.113.0

v0.112.0

v0.111.0

v0.110.0

v0.109.0

v0.108.0

v0.107.0

v0.106.0

v0.105.0

v0.104.0

v0.103.0

v0.102.0

v0.101.0

v0.100.0

v0.99.0

v0.98.0

v0.97.0

v0.96.0

v0.95.0

v0.94.0

v0.93.0

v0.92.0

v0.91.0

v0.90.0

v0.89.0

v0.88.0

v0.87.0

v0.86.0

v0.85.0

v0.84.0

v0.83.0

v0.82.0

v0.81.0

v0.80.0

v0.79.0

v0.78.0

v0.77.0

v0.76.0

v0.75.0

v0.74.0

v0.73.0

v0.72.0

v0.71.0

v0.70.0

v0.69.0

v0.68.0

v0.67.0

v0.66.0

v0.65.0

v0.64.0

v0.63.0

v0.62.0

v0.61.0

v0.60.0

v0.59.0

v0.58.0

v0.57.0

v0.56.0

v0.55.0

v0.54.0

v0.53.0

v0.52.0

v0.51.0

v0.50.0

v0.49.0

v0.48.0

v0.47.0

v0.46.0

v0.45.0

v0.44.0

v0.43.0

v0.42.0

v0.41.0

v0.40.0

v0.39.0

v0.38.0

v0.37.0

v0.36.0

v0.35.0

v0.34.0

v0.33.0

v0.32.0

v0.31.0

v0.30.0

v0.29.0

v0.28.0

v0.27.0

v0.26.0

v0.25.0

v0.24.0

v0.23.0

v0.22.0

v0.21.0

v0.20.0

v0.19.0

v0.18.0

v0.17.0

v0.16.0

v0.15.0

v0.14.0

v0.13.0

v0.12.0

v0.11.0

v0.10.0

v0.9.0

v0.8.0

v0.7.0

v0.6.0

v0.5.8

v0.5.7

v0.5.6

v0.5.5

v0.5.4

v0.5.3

v0.5.2

v0.5.1

v0.5.0

v0.4.0

v0.3.0

v0.2.2

v0.2.1

v0.2.0

v0.1.3

v0.1.2

v0.1.1

v0.1.0

v0.0.18

v0.0.17

v0.0.16

v0.0.15

v0.0.14

v0.0.13

v0.0.12

v0.0.11

v0.0.10

v0.0.9

v0.0.8

v0.0.7

v0.0.6

v0.0.5

v0.0.4

v0.0.3

v0.0.2

v0.0.1

Labels

Clear labels

burndown-2026-06

Backlog burndown June 2026

pressure-test

Cold-read release pressure-test findings and coordination

sunday-sprint

Burn-down by Sunday 2026-06-07

coherence-core

Core review set for the warded control plane coherence milestone. These issues form the release spine; adjacent milestone issues are stretch or supporting work.

consult

A human decision, design, or external action must happen first. Fail-closed default for unlabeled/low-confidence.

headless

Agent can take it from open issue to merged change with no human in the loop. The auto-burndown queue.

interactive

Agent does the work but pauses at a human checkpoint mid-flight (design choice, destructive step, human-only verification).

now / blocking / urgent

next / important

backlog / will do

someday / low

icebox / frozen / reopen if it becomes real

No labels

Milestone

Clear milestone

No items

No milestone

Projects

Clear projects

No items

No project

Assignees

Clear assignees

No assignees

1 participant

Notifications

Due date

The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference

coilyco-flight-deck/ward#1250

Reference in a new issue

Repository

coilyco-flight-deck/ward

Title

Body

No description provided.

Delete branch "%!s()"

Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?

Rows
Columns