Decide the fate of tooling-ceo-* and tooling-advisor-* composed skills #976

New issue

Open

opened 2026-08-08 18:49:21 +00:00 by coilyco-ops · 0 comments

coilyco-ops commented

2026-08-08 18:49:21 +00:00

Member

Follow-up from 48c48414, which removed the parked-config-block exclusion from [tool.agentic-os.code-comments] and deleted the parked role exec block from .agents/roles.kdl.

That block was the only thing in roles.kdl claiming two composed-skill families. Five sources now sit in .agents/composed/ unclaimed by any role:

tooling-advisor-causal-claim-audit
tooling-advisor-evidence-synthesis
tooling-ceo-developer-tool-adoption
tooling-ceo-oss-stewardship
tooling-ceo-platform-strategy

No validator fails on this. check_composed_skills does not read roles.kdl, so the suite stays green either way. The skills are simply never promoted, because agent-compose selects by role allowlist.

Three options:

Add a live role exec to roles.kdl with the allowlist the parked block carried, activating the role.
Reassign the five skills to an existing role (director is the closest fit for the ceo family).
Delete the five composed sources as retired.

Worth noting that exec is still a member of ROLE_TERMS in agentic_os/agents_context_inventory.py:42-51, which is a doc-heading vocabulary rather than a roles.kdl cross-check, so it does not force the first option.

Follow-up from 48c48414, which removed the parked-config-block exclusion from `[tool.agentic-os.code-comments]` and deleted the parked `role exec` block from `.agents/roles.kdl`. That block was the only thing in `roles.kdl` claiming two composed-skill families. Five sources now sit in `.agents/composed/` unclaimed by any role: * `tooling-advisor-causal-claim-audit` * `tooling-advisor-evidence-synthesis` * `tooling-ceo-developer-tool-adoption` * `tooling-ceo-oss-stewardship` * `tooling-ceo-platform-strategy` No validator fails on this. `check_composed_skills` does not read `roles.kdl`, so the suite stays green either way. The skills are simply never promoted, because agent-compose selects by role allowlist. Three options: * Add a live `role exec` to `roles.kdl` with the allowlist the parked block carried, activating the role. * Reassign the five skills to an existing role (director is the closest fit for the ceo family). * Delete the five composed sources as retired. Worth noting that `exec` is still a member of `ROLE_TERMS` in `agentic_os/agents_context_inventory.py:42-51`, which is a doc-heading vocabulary rather than a `roles.kdl` cross-check, so it does not force the first option.

coilyco-ops added the

labels

2026-08-17 02:36:52 +00:00

coilyco-ops referenced this issue

2026-08-17 02:40:19 +00:00

Nothing validates .agents/roles.kdl against the composed catalogue, which is why a deleted role block and three orphaned methods both went unnoticed #1076