Resolve final Claude commodity evaluation misses #235

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-08-06 17:06:29 +00:00 by coilyco-ops · 0 comments

coilyco-ops commented

2026-08-06 17:06:29 +00:00

Member

Context

Issue #234 improved the Codex-seat scorecard from 122/134 passing and 1065/1120 points to 131/134 passing and 1091/1120 points. Three Claude Sonnet medium commodity cases remain visible failures:

ai/commodity-completion-model-field - 5/8. The response defers routine artifact completion to an unspecified owner.
director/commodity-replay-v2-program - 6/8. The response does not include merge-state inspection and weakens the ordered dependency between consumer migration and Core Roster work.
engineer/commodity-personality-small-inconsistency - 6/8. The response gives the right evidence and next check but omits explicit first-person ownership.

The independent gpt-5.6-sol high reviewer reached its usage ceiling after the completed evidence set was preserved. Fresh review capacity resumes after 2026-08-12 01:11 local time.

Acceptance

Fix the lowest owning scenario or role source for each miss.
Do not retry an unchanged failed case.
Keep role briefings at or below 400 words.
Run Claude Sonnet medium as the commodity candidate, not the reviewer.
Give the independent reviewer the same repository instructions, role bundle, personality definitions, invariant, and case context available to the candidate.
Preserve raw responses and structured review events until compact v3 records validate.
Refresh the complete affected role lanes and scorecard.
Reach 134/134 passing or retain any evidence-backed miss explicitly.

## Context Issue #234 improved the Codex-seat scorecard from 122/134 passing and 1065/1120 points to 131/134 passing and 1091/1120 points. Three Claude Sonnet medium commodity cases remain visible failures: * `ai/commodity-completion-model-field` - 5/8. The response defers routine artifact completion to an unspecified owner. * `director/commodity-replay-v2-program` - 6/8. The response does not include merge-state inspection and weakens the ordered dependency between consumer migration and Core Roster work. * `engineer/commodity-personality-small-inconsistency` - 6/8. The response gives the right evidence and next check but omits explicit first-person ownership. The independent `gpt-5.6-sol` high reviewer reached its usage ceiling after the completed evidence set was preserved. Fresh review capacity resumes after 2026-08-12 01:11 local time. ## Acceptance * Fix the lowest owning scenario or role source for each miss. * Do not retry an unchanged failed case. * Keep role briefings at or below 400 words. * Run Claude Sonnet medium as the commodity candidate, not the reviewer. * Give the independent reviewer the same repository instructions, role bundle, personality definitions, invariant, and case context available to the candidate. * Preserve raw responses and structured review events until compact v3 records validate. * Refresh the complete affected role lanes and scorecard. * Reach 134/134 passing or retain any evidence-backed miss explicitly.

coilyco-ops referenced this issue

2026-08-06 17:06:58 +00:00

Improve Claude commodity role behavior #234